Read IIi again.
Here Shakespeare presents Polonius through conversations with Reynaldo (basically a personal spy) and Ophelia.
In the film version we saw Branagh presented Polonius as being immoral (remember the drink, cigar and prostitue). He is planning to spy on his own son and he seems to exploit Ophelia's grief for his own gain. However, maybe he is just a loving if over protective father.
Yes, I want to know what you think. Submit 50 words before Monday. Please use direct quotations of Polonius to support your case. It is okay to be ambivalent (look it up...)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
14 comments:
After reading Act 2 scene 1 it is clear that Shakespeare wants to portray Polonius as devious and cunning, this is supported by him 'employing' Reynaldo to spy on him. However, it seems that he is only doing it to make sure he is okay in Paris, 'inquire me first what Danskers are in Paris' suggests he wants to know who his son is hanging around with, to ensure he is not in any danger. This 'caring persona' vanishes though when we realise Reynaldo wants to catch out his friends '...drabbing. You may go so far' this implies Polonius WANTS Reynaldo to make up stories in the hope that Laertes' companions will reveal his inappropriate antics, supporting the sly image we get of him. It's as if he wants to catch him out 'your bait of falsehood takes this carp of truth' does he get an ego boost by catching his children out?
Similarly with Ophelia, we get the impression he is concerned as she enters distraughtly 'How now, Ophelia what's the matter?' but once again finding out news about Hamlet can be used to his own personal advantage, showing he is crafty. 'Come we go to the King. This must be known' may seem like he wants the King to know so Hamlet can receive help, however I think the true reason is so he can see Hamlet fall.
Overall on the surface I think Polonius comes across as a concerned father e.g. ' give him this money and these notes...' however his actions are always for his own gain.
Sorry Mr Benn this is alot longer than 50 words... :)
50 words as in a 50 word mini-essay?
I think that Polonius is being more of a controlling and overprotective father, rather than being a loving one. Spying on his son, to see if he’s doing anything deviant shows his controlling ways, as he has to know what they are doing. “Your bait of falsehood takes this carp of truth” is showing us that Polonius is telling Reynaldo that he has to lie to get the truth about Laertes doings.
When talking to his daughter Ophelia about Hamlet, it seems that perhaps he might be loving and protective over her, as he is concerned about her wellbeing. “Come go with me. I will go seek the King.” Polonius insist numerous times that they should go to the king to discuss the matter, maybe for the benefit of his daughter, or maybe just for himself.
At the beginning of Act 2 Scene 1, it is clear to us that Polonius wants to keep an eye on Laertes, by using Reynaldo as a personal spy. To me it seems as if he is being a concerned father, ‘Inquire me first what Danskers are in Paris’. However Polonius could be trying to control his son which is sneaky. “Before you visit him, to make inquire of his behaviour.” He comes across as a concerned father but i think that underneath I think he has different intentions.
When Ophelia enters, Polonius seems worried about her. “How now, Ophelia, what’s the matter?” He also inquires about her conversation with Hamlet “What said he?”. At first you think that he is genuinely worried but I think that he really wants to know about Hamlets state of mind so he can manipulate and get rid of him. Overall, Polonius is presented as an anxious father although we know he has hidden motives against Hamlet.
In this scene, Polonius is basically asking his man Reynaldo to spy on his son Laertes, "make enquire of his behaviour", however, it could also be said that Polonius is just looking out for his son, by keeping an eye on the company he has whilst in Paris, "Inquire me first what Danskers are in Paris". Polonius shows that his intentions are not so honourable when he asks Reynaldo to, in a way, make Laertes reveal his more inappropriate antics, “such wanton, wild and usual slips as are companions noted and most known to youth and liberty.”
In the second half of this scene we see Ophelia enter the room, frightened by her recent encounter with Hamlet. Like a caring father, Polonius seems to be genuinely worried for his daughter, “How now, Ophelia, what’s the matter?”, however, after she describes how Hamlet acted, he uses this to his advantage, by revealing Hamlets state of mind to the King it could show him as being unsuitable as a leader, “Come, go with me. I will go seek the King”, but at the same time, acting as if he is looking out for Hamlet, by informing the King of his strange behaviour, “Come, go we to the King. This must be known...”
Polonius gives the impression of being a loving and protective father; however, under the surface, we can see that he is digging for information to use against his son, through Reynaldo, and after seeming genuinely troubled by what Ophelia has told him, he still uses the information to his own advantage, showing how sneaky and deceitful his character is.
I thought that in this scene, Polonius is asking Reynaldo to spy on his son Laertes, "make enquire of his behaviour".
It also appears that Polonius lies to get the truth, which is very sneaky, "Ay, or drinking, fencing, swearing, quarrelling, Drabbing. You may go so far."So infact that Polonius makes out he knows the truth when he does not, so lies in order to get it.
"Your bait of falsehood takes this carp of truth" gives connotations of fish being caught. In this case it is his children being caught out and taking the "bait".
However, it appears that Polonius seems genuinely concerned for Ophelia when she enters, "With what, i'th'name of God?". However, he appears to think he knows it all (like most dads) "This is the very ecstasy of love". He believes he knows what is best to do, is this genuine concern and protectiveness for his daughter or control? "I will go seek the King".
Upon reading Act 2 Scene 1 I would argue that Shakespeare in fact wishes his intended audiences to see Polonius as quite a foolish and forgetful character. Shakespeare cleverly uses irony to portray an image of Polonius as an old fool who wishes to manipulate other peoples lives and make his own devious schemes, yet at the same time he cannot even remember where he left off whilst lecturing Reynaldo over his cunning plan from which his "bait of falsehood takes this carp of truth".
Why is my name slyman I didn't even put that!
Shakespeare seems to want us to think Polonius is being immoral by asking someone to spy on his son. He asks him to find out things such as "how, and who, what means, and where they keep, what company..." and also to find out whether he has been "drinking", "swearing" or "quarrelling". If he was simply being a concerned father he would ask Laertes what he was doing himself, and by asking about things like drinking, he clearly does not trust him and wants to prove himself right by being able to accuse Laertes of this.
However, Polonius seems much more caring towards Ophelia, and seems to be concerned about her when she tells him about Hamlet's state of mind. He acts as if he is looking out for Ophelia and Hamlet, "Come, go with me. I will go seek the King." But a part of the audience are thinking he has other intentions to get rid of Hamlet. Overall I think Polonius is supposed to look like a good, caring father to Laertes and Ophelia, but we are meant to see the deceitful side to him instead.
Well done you blog pioneers. Take time to read some of the other comments. It is interesting that no two are the same. I like especially how you have mixed impressions- like we might have for "real people." Maybe this supports the view again that Shakespeare has somehow captured the complexity of human character in his plays.
Elliot- I have no idea where Slyman came from if not from you..spooky.
Hello Fellow Students!
Hello Mr Benn
I have currently read Act 2, Scene 1. I thought that Polonius was portrayed as secretive as he was getting Reynaldo to spy, this is bad as it is his son who he is spying on, now a days you would just quiz your child rather than get someone to spy. On the other hand the audience could see Polonius as caring, as surely he just has his sons best intrests at heart. However I think Shakespeare wants Polonius to come across as negative to the audience in this seen and is seen as more of a devious character.
Anyway Hamlet Geeks
Will see you all in class where we can carry on learning the wonders of Hammy through the marvelous voice of Shakey the Shakespeare!
Lots of love SdotDAWSON da origonal badman of Silverdale lang lit :) (SlyMan is lameeeeeee at the side of me) xxxx
In this scene Polonius uses strong imperatives to make sure Reynaldo follows his orders. "Give him this money", "Observe his inclanation in yourself". This creates an atmosphere of urgency and makes us feel that Polonius isn't just spying on Laertes to make sure he is okay. The fact that Reynaldo actually protests at first to Polonius' orders makes the audience realise just how duplicitous Polonius is being. "My lord that would dishonour him", "But, my good lord-". Polonius is trying to make us think that he is doing is for Laerte's own good but it is actually a very immoral thing to do to spy on your son. Reynaldo is of a much lower authority than Polonius, so the fact that he is resisting his orders shows the audience just how devious Polonius is being.
Wadupp!
My view on this question is that Polonius is doing these things for his own personal gain rather than being a protective father. I believe that Shakesphere wants to portray him as sceheming and deceitful. Although he tries to make out he is doing for his children's best interest, for example spying on his son to make sure he is not going down a path of destruction. Not many parents go as far as that they simply ask their children what is going on and trust them, but he seems to lack this trust for some reason. He also acts like he is trying to help Ophila by going to the King after Hamelt pays her a rather odd visit however he has another hidden agenda, he is not worried about Hamlet hurting his daughter, he simply doesn't want her to be involved with him. The reason for this is not too clear however I believe that he feels threatened by Hamlet and his intelligence and believes that he may take Ophila away from him. There also could be a weird love interest between him and Ophila and he could be jealous.
Peace out
:)
I think that whilst Polonius is portrayed as an over protective and caring father, it soon becomes clear to the audience that he is quite cunning and scheming. This can be seen in the way that he is catch out the truth about his son Laertes with a 'bait of falsehood'. The word 'bait' implies that he is manipulative to the audience and makes them wonder why feels he needs to pry, could this really be to help his son or is it just a way of controlling everything around him? This question could also be asked of his relationship with his daughter Ophelia whom he has banned from seeing Hamlet. Although he does seem worried for her after their encounter, the fact that he chooses to go to the King could indicate that he is really out to benefit himself.
Post a Comment